Baltimore’s Top Internal Affairs Officer Is Now the One Under Investigation

A close-up of Baltimore's Internal Affairs Chief Brian Nadeau, with a serious expression, standing in front of a backdrop that includes the Baltimore Police Department emblem, alongside the text indicating he is under investigation by the Maryland State Police.

Brian Nadeau spent nearly seven years overseeing the internal affairs system that recommended which Baltimore police officers got disciplined, fired or cleared. Now Maryland State Police are investigating him, and a half dozen current and former officers say he manipulated their cases to reach predetermined outcomes.

By Michael Phillips | MDBayNews


BALTIMORE — For nearly seven years, Brian Nadeau occupied one of the most consequential positions for any Baltimore police officer facing internal scrutiny: the deputy commissioner who oversaw internal investigations and disciplinary recommendations that could end with a reprimand, a suspension or the loss of an officer’s job. Now he is the one under investigation.

Nadeau was suspended Sept. 15, and Maryland State Police have since agreed to investigate him, Baltimore Police confirmed. Commissioner Richard Worley has not said publicly why. The department has said the suspension is not related to Nadeau’s work investigating or disciplining officers, though officials have not offered an alternative explanation, and it is unclear how long the investigation will take.

Infographic detailing Brian Nadeau's timeline from the Baltimore Police Internal Affairs Chief to being under investigation, with dates and key events.

What is clear is that Nadeau was already facing scrutiny before the suspension. Over the past several years, most within the last two, a half dozen current and former Baltimore officers have filed federal and state lawsuits accusing him of running an internal affairs unit that retaliated against officers who complained and handed out uneven punishment. The cases name the department, Nadeau, or other BPD officials, though the defendants and surviving claims vary by case, and some claims against Nadeau have already been dismissed in earlier rulings.

  • A detective alleges he was fired at Nadeau’s direction over a minor timekeeping infraction.
  • An officer alleges Nadeau’s detectives leaked details of her internal complaint to a civilian who then harassed her.
  • Another detective alleges he was suspended over what investigators treated as marijuana use, when he was actually using a legal, nonintoxicating cannabinoid ointment to treat an on-duty injury from being struck by a drunk driver.
Infographic detailing allegations in lawsuits filed by Baltimore police officers against Brian Nadeau, highlighting claims of retaliation, predetermined outcomes, and unequal discipline.

One of those cases has already cleared a significant legal hurdle. Kenneth Phillips, a former BPD forensic science supervisor, sued Nadeau, then-Commissioner Michael Harrison, and the department, alleging he was fired in 2022 in retaliation for reporting a backlog of thousands of unprocessed forensic cases to city officials and the press. Phillips’ complaint alleges Nadeau ordered investigators to “recommend preordained findings” consistent with his own desired outcomes, language nearly identical to what officers in the other lawsuits allege. In January, Chief U.S. District Judge George L. Russell III dismissed several of Phillips’ claims but let his core First Amendment retaliation claims against Nadeau, Harrison and the department move forward, finding Phillips had pleaded enough for the case to proceed toward discovery. That does not mean the allegations are true, only that a federal judge found them specific enough to test in court.

Infographic summarizing the Phillips case against the Baltimore Police Department, detailing court information and outcomes as of January 28, 2026.

Andrew Alperstein, president of the Maryland Criminal Defense Attorneys’ Association, reviewed the lawsuits and said the allegations, if proven true, could discourage officers from trusting the internal affairs process at all.

“It just leads to a lack of confidence by everybody,” Alperstein said.

Sgt. Mike Mancuso, the outgoing president of the Fraternal Order of Police lodge representing Baltimore’s rank and file, said he is familiar with the allegations behind Nadeau’s suspension, though he declined to disclose them. He does not think Nadeau should come back.

“I do not believe he would be able to fulfill his duties,” Mancuso said.

The irony is that Nadeau was recruited to fix exactly the kind of internal affairs dysfunction he now stands accused of perpetuating. He joined the department in September 2019, two years into a federal consent decree imposed after Freddie Gray’s 2015 death in police custody, ordering Baltimore Police to overhaul how it investigated its own officers. The department was still absorbing the fallout from the Gun Trace Task Force corruption scandal, which had broken around the same time the decree took effect. Then-Commissioner Michael Harrison brought him in from the FBI, where Nadeau had spent more than two decades, including work investigating organized crime and leading a public corruption unit, before rising to assistant special agent in charge of the bureau’s Baltimore division.

Infographic detailing the timeline of Brian Nadeau's involvement with the Baltimore Police Department, highlighting key events from 2015 to 2026 related to police investigations and reforms.

For years, the officials overseeing that consent decree praised him publicly. At a 2021 hearing, U.S. District Judge James Bredar, who monitors the department’s compliance, singled Nadeau out by name.

“I don’t think any other part of the department more needed a complete makeover,” Bredar said.

But the praise from the bench came alongside quieter friction inside the department. Nadeau’s own numbers show the problem never fully went away. Internal investigations have moved faster on his watch, with a growing share resolved within six months, but a backlog of hundreds of cases still stands between the department and full consent decree compliance, according to an April report from the Daily Record.

Not everyone who worked under Nadeau describes him as heavy-handed. Joe Landsman, a former Baltimore detective who worked under Nadeau on an FBI gang task force before Nadeau joined the police department, described him as supportive and largely hands-off with his team’s casework.

“Every time he came down, it was always, ‘Whatever you guys need,'” Landsman said.

A graphic titled 'Two Separate Questions' outlining allegations against a police official named Nadeau regarding lawsuits and an investigation by the Maryland State Police.

Whether that same restraint carried over once Nadeau was running Baltimore’s own internal affairs shop is a question raised by the lawsuits, even as a separate state police investigation examines allegations that Worley has said are unrelated to Nadeau’s handling of internal cases. David Jaros, faculty director of the University of Baltimore’s Center for Criminal Justice Reform, said it is too early to know which account is closer to the truth: an internal affairs chief who overreached, or a reform effort facing resistance from the rank and file it disciplined.

“What remains unclear is whether or not this is internal resistance,” Jaros said.

For now, Baltimore is without its internal affairs chief and without a public explanation for why. Worley has given no timeline for when, or whether, Nadeau returns.

Graphic discussing key questions regarding the investigation of Baltimore's internal affairs chief under the Maryland State Police.

What to Watch

  • Whether Maryland State Police release any findings, or whether the investigation’s conclusions become public at all.
  • How the pending federal and state lawsuits involving Nadeau, the department and other BPD officials proceed, and whether any go to trial.
  • Whether Baltimore names a permanent replacement to lead the Public Integrity Bureau if Nadeau does not return.

Sourcing: This article draws primarily on Baltimore Banner reporter Alex Mann’s Sept. 25, 2026, report, “Hired to overhaul internal probes, suspended Baltimore Police commander faces scrutiny,” with additional reporting from Justin Fenton, and the Banner’s Sept. 16, 2026, report on Nadeau’s initial suspension. Additional details on the Maryland State Police investigation came from the Baltimore Sun’s Sept. 17, 2026, report and Fox45/WBFF’s Sept. 18, 2026, report. Details on Kenneth Phillips’ lawsuit came from Fox45/WBFF’s reporting and the U.S. District Court for Maryland’s Jan. 28, 2026, memorandum opinion in Phillips v. Baltimore Police Department, et al. (Civil Action No. GLR-25-1231). Details on the separate Lilly litigation came from the U.S. District Court for Maryland’s Feb. 25, 2026, memorandum opinion in Lilly et al. v. Harrison et al. (Civil No. 25-00240-BAH). Lawsuit allegations described in this article have not been proven in court. Nadeau and the department have contested claims against them, and courts have dismissed some claims while allowing others to proceed.


Keep MDBayNews Reporting Free

MDBayNews exists to help Marylanders understand decisions made by state and local leaders — especially when those decisions affect daily life, rights, and public services.

If this article helped clarify what’s happening or why it matters, reader support makes it possible to keep publishing clear, independent reporting like this.

👉 Support Local Journalism

Have a tip or documents to share?

We review submissions carefully and confidentially. Anonymous tips are welcome when appropriate.

 👉 Submit a Tip


Discover more from Maryland Bay News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply