By Michael Phillips | MDBayNews
For decades, mental health policy in America has been framed as a false choice:
“Bring back the asylums” vs. “Keep everyone in the community.”
That’s the wrong debate.
Modern psychiatric hospitals are not 19th-century asylums. They are short-term stabilization units designed to prevent suicide, treat acute psychosis, and manage crisis. They operate under strict legal standards shaped by the Olmstead v. L.C. decision, which requires treatment in the least restrictive setting possible.
But in Maryland today, we’ve swung so far toward community-first theory that we are ignoring a practical reality:
The state simply does not have enough psychiatric capacity for the people who truly need it.
The Modern Inpatient Unit: What It Actually Does
Let’s be clear about something.
Today’s inpatient psychiatric units are:
- Short-term (often 5–14 days)
- Focused on crisis stabilization
- Multidisciplinary (psychiatrists, nurses, social workers)
- Built around discharge planning from day one
They exist to:
- Remove access to means of self-harm
- Adjust medications quickly
- Stabilize psychosis or mania
- Provide 24/7 monitoring during the most dangerous period
This is not warehousing. It is emergency medicine.
And in severe cases — active suicidality, psychotic breaks, violent instability — it is often lifesaving.
The problem? Maryland does not have enough of it.
The Numbers Maryland Can’t Ignore
Maryland operates roughly 946–1,056 state psychiatric beds for a population of more than 6 million.
That’s about 15–17 beds per 100,000 residents.
National policy groups recommend 40–60 beds per 100,000 as a minimally adequate benchmark.
Even if you disagree with the upper bound, Maryland is operating at roughly one-third of what experts consider necessary.
The consequences are measurable:
- Patients boarding in emergency rooms for days
- More than 200 individuals waiting in jail for court-ordered psychiatric treatment
- Judicial fines against the Maryland Department of Health exceeding $1.5 million for delayed transfers
- Repeated 30-day readmission rates near 20% in some jurisdictions
This is not theoretical. It is a system under strain.
The Forensic Backlog: Jail as Default Mental Health Care
Facilities like the Clifton T. Perkins Hospital Center are routinely at capacity.
That means defendants found incompetent to stand trial wait in county jails — sometimes for months — for a hospital bed.
So what has deinstitutionalization produced in practice?
Not community care.
Transinstitutionalization.
We closed hospitals and replaced them with:
- Jails
- Homeless encampments
- Emergency rooms
That’s not compassionate. It’s chaotic.
What SB 870 and HB 1092 Tell Us
The General Assembly knows there’s a problem.
Maryland Senate Bill 870 and Maryland House Bill 1092 require at least 24 new licensed adolescent psychiatric inpatient beds in Prince George’s County.
Why?
Because children in psychiatric crisis are boarding in ERs for 30+ hours.
This is targeted expansion. Not asylums. Not mass institutionalization.
Just basic capacity.
The fact that legislators are carving out specific counties for mandatory bed minimums tells you everything about the statewide shortage.
Where Community Care Works — And Where It Fails
Community-based care absolutely works for the majority of patients with serious mental illness.
Programs like:
- Assertive Community Treatment (ACT)
- Assisted Outpatient Treatment (AOT)
- Supported housing
- Crisis stabilization units
— are humane and effective.
But here is the uncomfortable truth:
A small subset of patients — perhaps 5–10% — repeatedly fail in less restrictive settings.
They cycle through:
- Short-term hospitalizations
- Medication noncompliance
- Homelessness
- Arrest
- Release
- Repeat
This is the “revolving door.”
Short stays cannot fix treatment-resistant schizophrenia combined with substance use and trauma.
Sometimes, extended residential rehabilitation — 6 to 24 months — is the only environment where medication adherence, skill-building, and stability can take hold.
That is not an asylum.
That is structured rehabilitation.
The Risk of Overcorrection
The left often warns about returning to “warehousing.”
The right sometimes calls for “bringing back the asylums.”
Both oversimplify.
Long-term institutionalization absolutely caused abuse in the past. Dependency, neglect, and rights violations were real.
But pretending that zero long-term options is humane is just as flawed.
The Olmstead principle requires the least restrictive effective setting — not the least restrictive theoretical setting.
If someone is cycling between jail and the ER, we are already failing that principle.
The Fiscal Argument
Incarcerating a person with serious mental illness can cost $100,000+ per year.
Long-term structured psychiatric rehabilitation can cost $50,000–$80,000.
Emergency department boarding drains hospital resources.
Repeated hospitalizations are expensive.
Ignoring capacity shortages doesn’t save money. It shifts costs to law enforcement, corrections, and taxpayers.
What Maryland Actually Needs
Maryland does not need to resurrect 1950s-style asylums.
It does need:
- Increased acute psychiatric bed capacity
- Expanded forensic beds to reduce jail backlogs
- Targeted adolescent psychiatric beds (as proposed in SB 870 / HB 1092)
- Limited, recovery-oriented long-term residential rehabilitation for treatment-resistant cases
- Continued expansion of community services
This is not ideological. It’s operational.
The Center-Right Reality
A responsible, center-right approach recognizes:
- Personal liberty matters.
- Coercion should be limited.
- Institutions should never become warehouses.
- Community-based care should be prioritized.
But public safety and basic human stability also matter.
Allowing severely ill individuals to spiral into homelessness or incarceration in the name of ideological purity is not compassionate governance.
It’s abdication.
Maryland doesn’t need to “bring back the asylum.”
It needs to admit that deinstitutionalization without full replacement capacity created a structural hole — and that hole is showing up in ER hallways, jail waiting lists, and family crises across the state.
The answer is balance.
Community first.
Institutional when necessary.
Always humane.
Always accountable.
Keep MDBayNews Reporting Free
MDBayNews exists to help Marylanders understand decisions made by state and local leaders — especially when those decisions affect daily life, rights, and public services.
If this article helped clarify what’s happening or why it matters, reader support makes it possible to keep publishing clear, independent reporting like this.
Have a tip or documents to share?
We review submissions carefully and confidentially. Anonymous tips are welcome when appropriate.
Discover more from Maryland Bay News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.